Monarchy is an Outdated, Illogical & Flawed System of GovernmentLetter to a MonarchistIntroductionDear Admzad:
I have just got back from overseas, read your post and now I have to respond to it. You do understand that I have the highest respect for you. I consider you a friend, an artist, an intellectual (not In-Tell-Egg-Chew-All) and a good man. Everything that I will state here is not meant to be insults but they are facts, so do not get offended but instead take a look in the mirror to see the reality and judge yourself before judging others.
Yek suzan be khod zan, qabl az in ke yek javalduz be mardom zani!“Stick a pin in your own skin before you stick a needle in public’s skin!”
(Persian Expression)
Now let’s Rock & Roll:
BackgroundI am responding to this post:
Admzad Postviewtopic.php?p=9145#p9145For those of you who have no clue who Admzad is, there you go:
Admzad Indexhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/authors/admzad/index.htmAdmzad is an old activist, artist, graphic designer, writer and a friend.Admzad,
I am going to be very blunt with you because that is how I am.
Over 10 years ago, you quit activism, closed your site, stopped writing, quit graphic design, seized posting and basically quit politics.
First,I urged you to continue writing, drawing and activism.
You said, no one cares, no one reads and no one rises up against IRI.
I said, you must keep up the good work and never disappoint.
Second,Your political activism became limited to once a blue moon posting in the club and sending me e-mails.
To motivate you and keep your work alive, I published all your major material in IPC. I personally format, designed and published them.
You said, no one cares, no one reads and no one rises up against IRI.
I said, you are wrong. Check the stats and see many read and view your writings and art.
Since over 10 years ago, you quit writing and drawing. You seized your activities. You killed yourself. You made yourself irrelevant.Because you are a talented writer and artist, I kept you alive on the life support. I kept you alive online. I kept you relevant.Seasonal ActivistsSince then, every 3 years you show up and post a rhetorical nonsense in the club.
Same as you, Reza Pahlavi (your Hee-Row) also shows up every 3 years and conducts some 3 minutes interviews with international and Iranian media. Every time we (The True Opposition) create a hairy situation inside Iran and things get rowdy, Reza Pahlavi shows up with his 3 minutes interviews, only to state that he is still alive and relevant!Monarchists are Not Men of BattleIt is not only you and RP but it is the Monarchists by majority (not in general) who are inactive, indifferent and let’s be blunt, useless! Almost every monarchist that I know, have abandoned the battle ground, become irrelevant, seized political activity, and indeed become useless.
Monarchists by majority are not “
Men of Battle”. Monarchists are “Half Way Comrades”. They never stick with the struggle. They abandon the battleground. They have various reasons such as attending to personal life, cowardice, being cautious, indifference, being busy and so on. The reality is that they are not cut from the same cloth as brave activists. They are “
Middle of the Road Friends”!
I am using your creative terms such as “In-Tell-Egg-Chew-All” and “Hee-Row” because you are the master terminologist of the creative Penglish terms! This way, you relate better!
Now let’s dig in:
Letter to a MonarchistYou stated:
“So not every monarchy is good, depends who v r talking about.”
The argument here is not about good or bad monarchy but it is about the “System of Monarchy” which is outdated, illogical and flawed. Of course, there were useless monarchs and there were hardcore nationalist monarchs but this is not the argument. I am saying that the Monarchy as a system of government is outdated, illogical and flawed. I have proven it and it is done:
Why Monarchy has Ended and We Must Start a New?http://iranpoliticsclub.net/politics/wh ... /index.htmHow Republicans and Monarchists view the world?http://iranpoliticsclub.net/philosophy/ ... /index.htmJudgement of the Qajar DynastyYou stated:
“qajarollAhi hA ridand be Iran.
So, they can go to hell.”
Once again you are generalizing. You cannot generalize a Dynasty as a whole. As you stated yourself, there were good and bad monarchs and also there are good and bad people.
If your criticism is pointed at me being a Qajar, I do not get offended but I prove with logic that you and the critics of Qajar are wrong.
Let’s say that
Iran of today, in one piece as a nation exists because of the sacrifices and hard work of Aqa Khan. Aqa Mohammad Shah Qajar (primarily) and Reza Shah the Great (secondarily) kept Iran intact or else, long ago, Iran would have been disintegrated in to many pieces.
The last Persian Emperor (Aqa Khan) kept Iran as an empire and he fought with the skin of his teeth to keep it intact.
Abbas Mirza, his nephew was one of the greatest Iranian military generals of all time.
Qajar gave you and Iran, Culture, Civilization, Art, Painting, Poetry, Literature and Identity. Take a good look at all the Qajar monuments, architecture, paintings, poetry, and literature which exists until this day.It is easy to talk Shiite about Qajar but it is hard to close eyes to the reality of what Qajar had done for Iran.
There is no argument here that majority of Qajar Shahs were useless but you cannot generalize. You are not a fan of Iraj Mirza but he is one of Iran’s greatest poets. Abbas Mirza is one of Iran’s greatest military strategists and you and Iran exist in one piece because Aqa Khan existed. So, let’s be fair judge of the history.
Just because you are a Pahlavi-ist, this does not make Qajar Dynasty garbage!
Why don’t you educate yourself, I know you like to read:
Last Persian Emperor: Aqa Mohammad Shah Qajarhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/library/eng ... /index.htmJudgement of the Pahlavi DynastyYou wrote:
“The fact is that Pahlavis loved Iran & saved Iran”
See, you people must make up your mind. Is Constitutional Monarchy practical and good or not?
If so, then how come Reza Shah abolished the legitimate and Traditional Constitutional Monarchy of Ahmad Shah Qajar?
Why Constitutional Monarchy Will Never Work in Iran?viewtopic.php?p=8955#p8955OK, let’s for the argument sake, say that Ahmad Shah was a bum but Ahmad Shah’s Constitutional Monarchy was the most legitimate and Traditional Constitutional Monarchy which Iran ever had! Then why did Reza Shah abolish it?
Because Constitutional Monarchy does not work in Iran. That’s why!
Reza Shah ended it and started an “Absolutist Monarchy” and a “Nationalist Dictatorship”. Get it?
Reza Shah was a true Republican but Reactionary Monarchists and Shiite Clerics would not allow him to create a Republic in Iran:
Reza Shah The Great, The Real Storyhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/reza-shah/index.htmI know you have read all my work but read it again, this time in depth!
Pahlavi Dynasty had done many goods for Iran. There is no dispute there. Reza Khan was Father of the Nation. Alahazrat was a great Nationalist and had done many goods for Iran:
White Revolution of Shah and Peoplehttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/whi ... /index.htmToward the Great Civilizationhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/gre ... /index.htmAnswer to Historyhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/ans ... /index.htmShah of Iran Comic Bookhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/cartoons/sh ... /index.htmBut any way you look at, on his watch, Iran was handed to Islam (for the second time around)! No matter how much goods he had done for Iran, still historically, he will be remembered as the last Shah who lost the Imperial Iran to the Islamists.My beef with Alahazrat is not only losing Iran to the Islamists but also his cowardice, abandoning Iran in 2 occasions on 1953 and 1979. I do not care that he had cancer or what, but he did not stand his ground and fight but instead he fled!
Another issue was him to scapegoat his close comrades, cabinet and statesmen; furthermore, jailing them for no reason whatsoever! Example Hoveyda! So Hoveyda and likes of him were jailed for no reason at all but Pahlavis stole Billions and fled Iran!
Reasons for the birth of Islamic Republic of Iranhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/birth-IRI/index.htmThe Orchid Manhttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/founder/orc ... /index.htmMonarchs and Monarchists: Their 21st Century Rolehttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/history/monarchy/index.htmFanaticismYou always speak of “Ta’asob” (Fanaticism) and how bad it is to be a fanatic but you, yourself have a “Ta’asob” (Fanaticism) towards Pahlavis! You see the good they have done but you refuse to see the flaws! You refuse to see the crimes!
I, on the other hand, do not deal with Fanaticism but I deal with historical facts because I am a scientific historian!
“so, I vote for them any day, I owe them so much.”
You said it, you are a blind follower of Pahlavis! You are a fanatic. You are a hypocrite. You are not a logical person! Frist you speak bad about fanatics but then again, you are a fanatic and behave like a fanatic!So, what you say is that because Reza Shah and Mohammad Reza Shah had done some good for Iran, then you and the Monarchists must support Reza Pahlavi! Just because his last name is Pahlavi!
Do you see how illogical, flawed and baseless is this statement?
Historical FactsReza Khan was father of the nation, he had Balls of Steel
Alahazrat was flawed but done many good, he had Balls of Copper
Reza Pahlavi is a bum with Cotton BallsYou cannot generalize and judge a dynasty but you must judge the characters separately.Reza Pahlavi is a Block to End IRIReza Pahlavi is one of the major blocks and major reasons that for 40 years, we the Iranian Opposition were not able to get rid of the IRI and the Mullahs.
If RP would get the hell out of politics and abdicate his claim to the crown and monarchy, then all of these numb nut monarchists would finally comprehend that the monarchy is done with and RP is done with, so then they will sit down and seriously work with the Republicans to free Iran, but Noooooooooooooo this Useless Bum has been wasting the Iranian people’s time for 40 years!
Game of ThroneRP is a coward, a bum and a useless leech who had done nothing for 40 years to free Iran. He wants the people to revolt, free Iran and then erect him as a Shah! For 40 years he had been playing this game of throne with the Iranians!
First, he wanted to become Shah, then President, then Shah again and now whatever! He simply will not pack the hell up and leave for the kitchen where he belongs. He is a good cook, so he must attend his kitchen and cook. Leave politics and activism for real activists.
In addition, with a slight threat and bribe by IRI, he made a deal with the Mullahs to only talk but no action. In return he got his hush money! Stay tune for my future expose on the deal RP made with the Mullahs.
Why Iran is FAQed?So, people like you support RP only because you owe Pahlavis this much! And you wonder why Iran is FAQed? Iran is FAQed because of people like you with this mentality! Iran will always be FAQed because of Fanatics like you who claim to be Logical, Practical, Open Minded, Free Thinking but in really, they are simply Fanatics!
Buddy, you are the worst of “Mote’asebs”. You have “Ta’asob” towards Pahlavis. What is the difference between you and that Hezbollahi in Qom tearing his ass apart for Khomeini? You do the same for Pahlavis!
I want you to read this post over and over and seriously think about everything that I am stating here.
Fanaticism is Fanaticism, may it be towards Imam or Shah.
The Dialogue Reza Pahlavi II Could Not Enter!http://iranpoliticsclub.net/politics/re ... /index.htmWhy Reza Pahlavi Cannot Lead Iranian Opposition?http://iranpoliticsclub.net/politics/why-shah/index.htmI am a Pragmatist“Just follow mehrA maleki to find historical facts, not the BS KIRollAhi hA & most-deq hA have been saying.”
No, just open your eyes to History and open your heart to Reality because 40 years of stagnation by you monarchists have been a crime towards the motherland! Stop your Fanaticism and start being logical.
You know very well that,
I am not a Mossadeghist but a great critic of Mossadegh
I am not a Hezbollahi but a great opposition to Hezbollah
Neither am I a Tribalist of 1001 opposition groups of left, center and right
But I am pure logic; therefore, I work with all of them.
You bash the Opposition of 1979 but if we don’t work with all the opposition groups including opposition of 1979, then how the hell are we going to free Iran from IRI? According to you, we shall not work with Mojahedin, Marxists, Jebhe Meli, Meli Mazhabi, Socialists, Revisionists, Republicans and many, then what the hell should we do?
Should we become like you, nagging about 40 years ago and cuss the Opposition groups, worship Pahlavis, remain faithful to Reza Shash de Zepert de Nim Pahlavi for another 40 years?
Baba jan, you are not an illiterate man, on the contrary, you are an educated and bright man, so open your eyes! Read what you wrote in your post, twice, three time and more. See how illogical, impractical and fanatical you sound!
Constitutional Monarchy is ObsoleteYou stated:
“jAvid shAh!”
What Shah? Pahlavi Dynasty ended 40 years ago. Good or bad, they are done with. Constitutional Monarchy is an outdated, illogical and flawed system of government. If it worked, then Reza Khan would not abolish it.
Constitutional Monarchy is nothing but discrimination by heredity. Constitutional Monarch is nothing but a leech sucking the blood of the masses. He is a useless bum, a burden on taxpayers’ back who must support him financially. At least the Absolutist Monarch has a job, a purpose and a duty. A Constitutional Monarch is a waste of oxygen!
British Rotten MonarchyThink about it, as an Australian, Canadian and British, all of you are “
Subjects of Her Majesty the Queen”. You are not even Freemen! As an American, I am a Freeman! They do not even refer to you as a Freeman!
The British Subjects work hard and pay taxes to finance the Queen, British Monarchy and their lifestyle! You are nothing but Subjects. You are subjects who keep some monarch in her or his monkey suit alive!Future IranNow you want to bring this garbage to Iran and put a monkey suit on RP and declare him King! Buddy, I rather eat Shiite and die than to work in the future Iran, pay taxes and to finance this Faggot Bum’s lifestyle and his lousy family’s luxurious habits! Over my dead body, future Iran will once again become the grazing ground for a bunch of cows (Gav O Guspand as you say) to roam around worshiping some Shah, Imam, Dictator or some other Dayus!
Nature of MonarchyThe problem with you people is that world progressed but you lagged behind! The world evolved but monarchists are still modeling the Dead Monarchies of the “Euro-Pee-On Nations” as role models! Baba jan Monarchy died and people have evolved since the 18th century! A handful of Kos Kholz still cling to their cheesy monarchs in Europe as symbols of unity and in Asia as thug dictators!
European Flawed MonarchiesWhy on earth would a free human being admit that he is a subject of some monarch? Why on earth would a free human being admit that he is inferior to some monarch because of heredity? Monarchy is discrimination against the masses!
Do you know why these
Euro-Pee-On Nations have lost their colonial glory? Because of Monarchy! Now they are little toy nations with their puppet monarchs living happily ever after in their storybook powerless socialist countries like UK, Netherland, Sweden Belgium, Spain and so on! They all live in their little Environmentally PC LaLa Land!
American ExceptionalismDo you know why America only after a couple of centuries rules the world? Because in America, president is relevant, has a job, has a purpose, has a life and True Unique Democracy in US has no match elsewhere in the globe!
In America, we do not have the nonsense of having a head of state and a head of government! Why on earth do you need two?Buddy, Freemen such as me have stopped supporting Dictatorial Monarchs on 1979 and surely Useless Constitutional Monarchs for 40 years!
I do not owe or support a Dynasty because they done some good for Iran.
I support government of the people by the people and for the people.
I rather die than refer to myself as a British Subject or Subject of some Monarch!This is why on 1776, we the Americans made a Revolution and created America.
We did so to throw the garbage of the British monarchy in the harbor like the tea in Boston!
Unfortunately, some people will always be followers and blindly follow some Kos Kholz on YouTube, TVs and Radios preaching Bull Shiite on how to be Obedient Dogs faithful to Pahlavis and Monarchy! Some people are born slaves, you are correct! However, you fail to see that the Hezbollahi in Qom is as much of a slave to Imam as you people are slaves to a Shah!
FreemenBuddy, Freemen and freewomen can never accept themselves as subjects of some monarch, supreme spiritual leader, dictator or puppet constitutional monarch!
Freemen are born free, live free and die free.There is no difference between you and RP. He has no superiority over you. Only because his father was a Pahlavi, this does not make him eligible by merit! Monarchy is truly discrimination by heredity. We said goodbye to this garbage on 1979. Never again we will be slave to any one God, Dictator, Shah, Imam or another Figurehead. You simply do not get it because you simply have never evolved to become a Free Man!
You were an Imperial Iranian Subject of Alahazrat and then you became the Imperial British Subject of Queen in Australia! In a way, all your life, you have been a Subject. You have never become a Freeman!
Soon or late Iranians must learn to become Free Men and Women without some dictator banging on their heads and refer to them as subjects. The Free Men build the world upon their merit. They will never accept subjecthood!Plastic WarriorsBuddy, now most likely you will go away and come back in 3 years (like Reza Pahlavi) to lineup some meaningless rhetoric. Same as Reza Pahlavi, you have made yourself “Irrelevant” in our struggle to Free Iran. You have abandoned the Struggle, Writing, Drawing and Activism 10 years ago. Fortunately, I have been keeping you alive on life-support in IPC now for over 10 years! Unlike you and Monarchists, I am man of the battle and I have been fighting with IRI now for 40 years. I do not have the luxury of being a part-time and seasonal activist!
On 1979, I made an oath of honor to the blood of our nationalist revolutionaries to never forget their sacrifices and always to fight IRI. Since then, I have been keeping my word and my struggle to fight IRI. Unlike Monarchists who struggle with booze, nicotine and opium, I take this struggle seriously and I struggle with life and death to keep this opposition alive until the death of IRI.
Yes buddy, my comrades and I are men and women of battle because we have taken a blood oath!
Take it from the Plastic Persian:
Plastic Persian 1: Persian Sunsethttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/art-literat ... /index.htmPlastic Persian 2: Persian Sunrisehttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/art-literat ... /index.htm“The Further and Greater your Dreams are, the Further and Greater your Efforts will become.”Ahreeman X Famous Persian Quoteshttp://iranpoliticsclub.net/philosophy/ ... /index.htmNow please go and take a good look in the mirror while thinking about everything which I have stated to you.Best wishes to you and your family
No Gods
No Shahs
No Imams
No Masters
No Prophets
I bow to no Gods.
I serve no Masters.
I control my own destiny.
I am a Thinking Man.
I am a Free Man.
More Power to All Freedom Fighters of Iran
More Power to the People
Amen!
Dr. X